Digging into the topic of renewable energy last week, I became acutely aware how big an issue our current energy usage is today. In Energy Autonomy (2007), Dr. Hermann Scheer argues that our current reliance on traditional energies has resulted in (or augmented) what he calls the “seven energy-determined world crises” (the global climate crisis, the exhaustion and dependence crisis, the poverty crisis in the developing countries, the nuclear crisis, the water crisis, the farming crisis, and the health crisis). I believe that an honest consideration of Dr. Scheer’s argument brings about three potential responses.
First: Dr. Scheer is wrong and therefore these problems would not be alleviated if we altered our energy usage. Second: Dr. Scheer is right and we should therefore respond rapidly with more responsible energy usage. Third: There’s nothing that I can do (regardless of whether Dr. Scheer is right or wrong).
Individual research the past two weeks has brought me to this place… The preponderance of data suggests that Dr. Scheer is right in many of his claims. Therefore, as a citizen of the global community, I feel that it is my responsibility to work and advocate for a faster transition away from traditional energies and towards renewables.
In our discussion last week, we addressed a number of blockades to shifting the energy usage paradigm. Indeed, there’s a lot standing in the way. But if we take these crises seriously, I don’t think the third response (above) is an ethical option because of the potential severity for future generations.
The simple fact that the sun and it’s derivates supply more than 15,000 times our current usage in nuclear and fossil energies… coupled with our increasing scientific know-how/ engineering expertise… gives significant hope to the situation. The biggest hurdle is will-power.
The question – I believe – at the heart of this debate is about us as humans. Are we, as a society, inherently short-sighted and selfish or do we value the lives of those who are to come after us enough to make sacrifices now?